Tag Archive for is gregor a monster

Brainstorm Thursday

Standard: 

  • ELAGSE9-10W1 Write arguments to support claims in an analysis of substantive topics or texts, using valid reasoning and relevant and sufficient evidence.

Learning Target: I will begin brainstorming and collecting quotes for my argumentative essay on The Metamorphosis.

Opening Session: Finishing Alien from yesterday!

Work Session: Ok y’all, let’s get into writing your essay for this unit! Yaaaaay…..

Here’s the skinny:

Metamorphosis Close Reading Essay

Prompt:

Throughout the unit as we have read The Metamorphosis, we have discussed two possibilities for what is going on in the story: either Gregor has really transformed into a monster, or it is all in his head. For this essay, you will choose either “Team Transformation” or “Team Insanity” and argue your side using evidence from the story (quotes) to support your point. You must use at least four quotes from the story. As a reminder, all quotes must have a lead-in (no quote should stand on its own!) and your paper should focus on a single argument (do not switch sides!).

Requirements:

  • MLA Format (MLA heading, size 12 Times New Roman, double spaced)
  • 4 quotes from the story with MLA parenthetical citations
    • All quotes need a LEAD-IN!
  • MLA Works Cited (we will go over this in class)
  • At least 750 words
  • DUE TUESDAY, MARCH 21ST.

The first thing we need to do for this essay is write a thesis statement. This is one clear, strong sentence where you state what you’re arguing about and what side you’re on. You can use this stem to help you:

  • In Franz Kafka’s The Metamorphosis, it is clear that the character Gregor (has/has not) actually transformed into a monster, and in fact he is _________________________ ____________________________________________________________.
    • (Examples for the blank:
      • “a giant monstrous vermin, as he is described in the book.”
      • “insane and his troubles are the result of extreme stress.”
      • “nothing more than an overworked and deranged man who has not transformed at all.”
      • “truly experiencing a great, mysterious, and tragic transformation that his family must now learn to cope with.”

Of course, you’re not required to use that stem at all!

After you have your thesis statement, I want to talk about lead-ins. This was an issue with our last essay! I saw a lot of this:

  • Dissatisfaction plays a major role in why communism has reached its high. “When any form of government, whether capitalist or communist, fails to meet the basic needs of its people, civil unrest is bound to follow.” (Why Didn’t Communism Work in Eastern Europe?). The quotes simplifies the basic reason why dissatisfaction from society prevents any form of communism to takeover completely in America.

The problem with that excerpt is that the quote is just sorta hanging out there. There’s an explanation after it, which is good, but it would be a billion times BETTER if we used a proper lead-in:

  • Dissatisfaction plays a major role in why communism has reached its high. Simply put, the basic reason why dissatisfaction from society prevents communist takeover in America is that “when any form of government […] fails to meet the basic needs of its people, civil unrest is bound to follow” (Why Didn’t Communism Work in Eastern Europe?).

Here is a super cool guide that should refresh your memory:

http://olympia.osd.wednet.edu/media/pagefiles/3189.tlq.pdf

One more thing for today: We need to do our MLA Works Cited!! It should look like this, everyone copy it down…

Kafka, Franz, and Stanley Corngold. “The Metamorphosis.” Prentice Hall Literature: World Masterpieces, Penguin ed., Pearson Education, Boston, MA, 2007, pp. 1066–1108.

For the rest of class, we’re going to collect your four quotes and write the lead-ins for them. Tomorrow you’ll be actually drafting your essays – we’re going to be downstairs in room 203 (that’s Ms. Gelston’s room!) using the laptop cart!

Closing Session: Share a lead-in with a partner and check that they’re doing it correctly!

Assessment: Formative checks for understanding, essay brainstorming grade

Differentiation: Process (modified/scaffolded essay); product (varied length of essay, modified quote requirements).

It’s FRIDAY!! Brainstorm!

Standard:

W.9-10.1. Write arguments to support claims in an analysis of substantive topics or texts, using valid reasoning and relevant and sufficient evidence.

  • Introduce precise claim(s), distinguish the claim(s) from alternate or opposing claims, and create an organization that establishes clear relationships among claim(s), counterclaims, reasons, and evidence.
  • Develop claim(s) and counterclaims fairly, supplying evidence for each while pointing out the strengths and limitations of both in a manner that anticipates the audience’s knowledge level and concerns.
  • Use words, phrases, and clauses to link the major sections of the text, create cohesion, and clarify the relationships between claim(s) and reasons, between reasons and evidence, and between claim(s) and counterclaims.
  • Establish and maintain a formal style and objective tone while attending to the norms and conventions of the discipline in which they are writing.
  • Provide a concluding statement or section that follows from and supports the argument presented.

Learning Target: Students will brainstorm and draft for their essay on The Metamorphosis.

Activator: 

Welcome to FRIDAY, y’all!!! I am SO looking forward to sleeping in tomorrow. Anyone else? Maybe you all have more exciting plans than me, hahaha.

Anyway, today you’re brainstorming and drafting for your essay for this unit!! We are in the lab on Monday to type your paper. Here’s the prompt:

Is Gregor a Monster?

Throughout this unit, we have talked over and over again about what it means to be a monster. For your close-reading argumentative essay, I would like you to take a closer look at Gregor from The Metamorphosis and determine whether or not he is a monster.

Consider the following:

  • What makes a monster? We have defined “monster” several times and in several ways throughout the unit. Which of these is most accurate and why?
  • Does Gregor fit the qualifications to be a monster? Why or why not?
  • What is the counterargument – the other side? What is the opposite of what you believe, and why is that incorrect?

You’ll have the entire class to brainstorm and draft your essay. The early writing we did yesterday is worth 10%  of your grade. The drafting today is worth 30% of your grade. The final draft of your essay, due on Monday, is worth the remaining 60%.

Good luck everyone, let’s get right to it!

Differentiation: Process – students will be provided a structured outline or sentence stems as needed; Product: Students for whom the final essay product would be unrealistic will complete a detailed outline.

Assessment: Essay will be graded as above.